Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Some Anon's avatar

Given that Ukraine was, by your predictions, stuck forever under Russian domination. It seems that it will have won a substantial victory by freeing itself and keeping most of its land.

Weird you can't see this.

Expand full comment
Anatoly Karlin's avatar

Good essay - though I think you are excessively bullish on Russia.

1) Manpower - KIA ratios have decidedly swung in Ukraine's favor, running at 2:1 or even 3:1 now and the inverse of 2022. As you correctly note, mobilization will now be very hard to implement. Even in 2022, the response rate was 20% (300k/1.5M), and produced 1M emigrated (of whom half came back). Both numbers are now going to be far worse now that it's well known the Russian Empire is the Hotel California (you can check out but you can never leave).

2) Hardware - again as you note, the Soviet stockpiles are shrinking fast and approaching depletion, esp. in artillery. New production is vastly lower than refurbishment. Any new mobilization under current circumstances will produce light infantry (read: drone fodder), perhaps they will call them the Putin Fedayeen.

3) Drones - Ukraine maintains a consistent and arguably expanding lead, and there's no cause to expect that to change in light of its integration into the Western technosphere.

My guess would be that this is now sufficient for Ukraine to stall Russia indefinitely, short of large-scale infusions of materiel from other big players (NATO and China for Ukraine and Russia, respectively; there being the chance that we mutually posit that it is perhaps ironically likeliest with Trump in the event that Putin rejects his "best deal").

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts